Actually, they all fell out when I opened the cabinet.
Apparently I already had a variety. Let's see. There's the new box on top, the huge bandages for skinned knees, the box of fingertip and knuckle bandages (with no knuckles left) a box of large flexible cloth ones from when I broke my big toenail, the Nextcare bandage box I've been dumping other boxes into, and the Angry Birds Space bandages that Junior begged me for.
There has to be a better way to do this, I thought. Here's what I came up with:
A plastic watertight 3 x 5 card file box. Watertight because it's bound to end up in the sink some time. This one came with index cards, which I actually used to organize the huge variety of bandages.